Juvenile Law Center

Juvenile and Criminal Justice

People of California v. Caballero

Juvenile Law Center, along with several other advocacy organizations, filed this brief in support of Rodrigo Caballero, who is appealing his sentence of 110 years to life (three consecutive life terms) for his conviction on three counts of attempted murder when he was a juvenile.

The brief argued that because California law requires Caballero to serve a minimum of 110 years before becoming parole-eligible, his sentence is the functional equivalent of life without parole for a non-homicide offense.  This sentence violates the United States Supreme Court’s ruling in Graham v. Florida, which held that juvenile offenders cannot be sentenced to life for non-homicide offenses without a meaningful and realistic opportunity for re-entry into society prior to the expiration of their sentence.

The brief thus argued Caballero’s sentence is unconstitutional because it serves no legitimate penological purpose and is disproportionate with respect to his age. The brief argued in addition that the court’s failure to consider Caballero’s significant mental illness at sentencing impacted the constitutionality of the sentence imposed. Finally, the brief argued that Caballero’s 110 year sentence violates United States treaty obligations as well as international practice and opinion.

The California Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeal's opinion, ruling that a 110-year-to-life sentence imposed on a juvenile convicted of nonhomicide offenses violates Graham's mandate against cruel and unusual punishment under the Eighth Amendment. 


In the News

"California Supreme Court issues landmark ruling prohibiting lengthy sentences for juveniles convicted of non-homicide crimes," Juvenile Law Center press release, 8/16/12

"One teen's fate: The math of a 100-year sentence," Teresa Chin, Youth Radio, 6/1/12

Details

Case Number
S190647
Type
Amicus Curiae
Date
October 30, 2011
Court
California Supreme Court
State of Origin
California